Do Christmas puddings go off? Your Christmas pudding questions answered!

  • We earn a commission for products purchased through some links in this article.
  • Do Christmas puddings go off? All your Christmas pudding questions answered! Our guide will answer any questions you might have about this classic festive dessert.

    For many, it wouldn’t be Christmas without a rich and fruity Christmas pudding. But if you find yourself confused and a bit daunted by this British Christmas classic, you’re not alone.

    From knowing when these little beauties should be eaten by to questions about the dietary specifications of a good old pud, we’ve gone through Google’s most commonly asked Christmas pudding questions and made sure we have an answer for you.

    Read our handy guide to find out all you need to know about this festive family favourite.

    Do Christmas puddings go off?


    Christmas puddings are often made well in advance of Christmas, as they keep well and the flavours mature the longer you leave them – but how long can you safely keep these puds for? There is no concrete answer for this one, as it depends on the exact contents of the pudding, so check the recipe you use or package you buy. Any pudding using fresh fruit for moisture will go off quicker, whereas a Christmas pudding soaked in booze with a high sugar and dried fruit content will last much longer.

    Some Christmas puddings, made with dried fruit in the traditional way, are fine to be eaten even two years after they were made.

    If you still need some convincing, we spoke to Juliet Sear who shared her tips in partnership with the FAB Flour Easy Peasy Baking Campaign from the National Association of British and Irish Millers.

    The TV cook and baking expert confessed: ‘I’ve eaten out of date puds before, including my Christmas cake, which is a hybrid of a pud and cake – we’ve even eaten this after almost three years and I’m still standing!’

    Juliet added that as long as the pudding is stored correctly, it’s highly unlikely to go bad. She explained: ‘They don’t tend to go off if they are stored correctly in a cool place, eventually they may dry out or lose flavour, of course, the more alcohol the better – if it’s soaked in booze, it will stay preserved for a long time. I always do the sniff test, if something smells okay and there’s no signs of any mould then it should be okay.’

    How can you tell if Christmas pudding is safe to eat?

    If you made the Christmas pudding a while ago, or you’ve just discovered a shopbought one you scurried away and forgot about, there’s still a good chance it’s edible. Juliet suggests not eating the pudding if there are ‘any unpleasant smells or signs of deterioration like mould’. Put simply, ‘if in doubt, don’t eat anything you’re suspicious of’ says Juliet.

    Do you feed a Christmas pudding?

    If you are making your Christmas pudding ahead of time, or on the traditional day Stir Up Sunday, it’s good to feed your pudding to keep it moist. Depending on what you use to feed the pudding, it can also act as a preservative and prevent the pudding from developing mould or allowing the growth of any bacteria.

    Juliet reveals: ‘The way I feed my Christmas pudding is to pierce a few holes over the surface and spoon over 1-2 tablespoons of booze, every 2-3 weeks or so…

    Make sure you wrap it well, I double wrap in baking parchment, then seal over with a tight layer of foil and store back in a cool dry place. I keep mine in a box in the pantry. It’s not essential to do this if you’ve already fed it with plenty of booze after the first cook, but it does help to add flavour and moisture to the pudding.’

    What do you pour on Christmas Pudding?

    The most common thing to pour over a Christmas pudding to feed it is a form of alcohol. Juliet explains: ‘I favour brandy but some people like whisky or rum, just make sure it’s a spirit with a high alcohol content.’ It’s all down to personal preference but Juliet recommends not going too heavy-handed on the pouring!

    She suggests: ‘Just make sure not to really soak it too much over and over as you don’t want it super soggy, just add a little every so often.’

    You can experiment with the booze that you use in your Christmas pudding and you might develop a new favourite family recipe. Juliet says: ‘Sometimes I do an orange version and add some Grand Marnier or Cointreau, it really is down to personal choice.’ You could try a flavoured gin or even a nod to your favourite high-alcohol cocktails like the classic negroni.

    If you would like an alcohol free option, you could try soaking your fruit in tea and feeding it with this for added flavour. Juliet suggests a spiced spring tea but you could try something floral like Earl Grey too.

    However, Juliet stresses: ‘Bear in mind if the pudding is alcohol-free, of course it will last a good while with the sugar content, but it will not last as long without alcohol to preserve it.’

    If you want to light the pudding on Christmas Day you will also need to use a high alcohol content spirit such as brandy, whisky or rum. Warm it gently before pouring into a ladle to light and pour over the pudding.

    Is Christmas pudding vegan?


    Many traditional Christmas puddings are made using suet, which means they are not suitable for vegans. Always check the label though, as this Co-op Irresistible Christmas Pudding is made with vegetable suet instead, and doesn’t contain eggs. It is made in the same factory as the regular puds though, so run this past your vegan guest to check how strict they are.

    If shop bought isn’t for you, you can make your own vegan Christmas pudding using our easy recipe.

    Is Christmas pudding vegetarian?


    The answer here is similar to the vegan question, apart from egg is suitable for vegetarians, so you don’t need to worry about finding an egg free version. We have a great recipe for a vegetarian Christmas pudding that tastes just as good as a classic pud.

    Can Christmas pudding be frozen?

    You can freeze a Christmas pudding, but if you’ve made your own in advance of Christmas, it is better to store in a cool dry place and let the flavours develop. If you’ve bought a Christmas pudding that you haven’t used, and want to freeze it, it should be safe to freeze for up to a year. Be sure to leave it at room temperature overnight to defrost.

    Can Christmas pudding be reheated?

    You can reheat a Christmas pudding, and there are several ways to do so. The easiest, and most convenient, way to do so is in the microwave. The time taken depends on the size of your pud, but we’d recommend placing the leftover Christmas pudding in a microwave safe bowl, covering with clingfilm, and microwaving on high for 3-4 minutes, allowing it to rest for a minute, and then repeating, until piping hot. Alternatively, you can wrap your Christmas pudding in foil and reheat in the oven for 1hr at 150C.

    Can Christmas pudding be eaten cold?


    Once cooked, you can eat any leftover Christmas pudding cold if you like. This isn’t the tastiest way to eat the fruity festive favourite (in our humble opinion), we’d recommend using the leftovers to make our Christmas pudding crumble instead.

    Can Christmas pudding be made in a slow cooker?

    If the old fashioned steaming method seems too daunting, you can actually make your Christmas pudding in a slow cooker. This is an easy, safe, and effective way to make your pud.

    Follow your Christmas pudding recipe as you normally would, filling a greased pudding basin with your home-made mixture and covering with a pleated piece of baking paper and foil to seal the top nice and tightly. Pour a couple of inches of boiling water into the bottom of your slow cooker. Turn onto high, lower your pudding basin full of Christmas pudding mixture into the slow cooker and cook for around 8-9 hours.

    Juliet also recommends this method of reheating your Christmas pudding, as she says: ‘I always find on the big day itself I really struggle to offer up a hob ring for my pudding to steam for hours. Since I got my slow cooker, it’s been a lifesaver as I have it turned on out of the way in the utility room heating up the pudding.’

    Is Christmas pudding the same as fruit cake?

    Christmas present cake

    Christmas pudding and Christmas cake are very similar due to the spices used and they form an integral part of Christmas for many. However, the key differences are in the way the two sweet dishes are cooked. Christmas cake is baked in an oven and is often topped with marzipan and/or royal icing. We’ve got lots of Christmas cake ideas with fun decoration inspiration to make the cake a truly special centrepiece for your festive table. Pictured above is our gorgeous Christmas present cake.

    However, Christmas pudding is steamed and is generally only decorated with a piece of holly traditionally. Some people also like to use fresh red currants and berries.

    Christmas cake generally only includes dried fruit, whereas Christmas pudding can include a mix of grated fresh fruit and dried fruit that has been soaked in alcohol or tea. You can make Christmas cake ahead of time and feed it with alcohol in a similar way to Christmas pudding. However, this means you have to delay finishing the cake with the icing and marzipan.

    Can I have a Christmas pudding without fruit?


    If you still aren’t sold on the idea of a traditional Christmas pudding, we have a great alternative Maltesers Christmas pudding that kids and adults will love! It looks like a Christmas pudding but it’s actually made of chocolate cake with a clever white chocolate drip.

    Have all your Christmas pudding questions been answered? Let us know how you get on in the comments below.